The Paulist Summit on Polarization:
Bridging the Divide, Seeking Reconciliation
April 19-21, 2024
Flamingo Hotel, Las Vegas

The event will bring together more than 100 Catholic leaders, academics, media experts, and Paulist representatives from diverse perspectives. Bound by mutual concern we will share stories, listen openly, and respond to the current climate of polarization in both our nation and our Church.

While the Initiative welcomes input from anyone willing to share their thoughts or experiences, capacity restrictions limit this event only to invited guests.

The Paulist Initiative on Polarization

The Paulist Initiative on Polarization emerged from the 2022 Paulist General Assembly with a specific goal in mind. It aims to effectively address and respond to the toxic polarization in our society, which hinders our ability to promote, practice, and achieve spiritual, emotional, and physical well-being. This impacts our local, diocesan, and national communities as well as the Church’s missionary endeavors.

As a first order crisis, polarization creates barriers for respecting differences and, as a result, impairs any process for constructive dialogue in current civic and moral issues, including abortion, climate change, immigration, gender and sexuality, gun control, racism, and secularization.

Twin Goals of Forming Alliances and Sustaining the Process

In order to effectively address polarization, the initiative needs (1) to form alliances and (2) sustain its efforts. 

Forming Alliances: first, given the complex dynamics that contribute to the present state of polarization, no single organization or social institution alone is capable of slowing down this trajectory. For this reason, the formation of alliances across institutional and ideological boundaries, both at local and national levels, is critical.

Sustaining the Process: second, because polarization has been building up over the past 60+ years, it is not likely to decrease sharply any time soon. For this reason, efforts to effectively respond to its toxicity need to be sustained by remaining relevant and vibrant beyond any one time gathering.

The 2024 Summit: Process, Goal, and Hopes

Process and Goal: Connected to the twin goals of creating alliances and sustaining our efforts, the 2024 Summit (April 19-21, 2024) will serve as the physical inauguration of the Initiative. It will involve a process of gathering 100+ leaders, experts, and Paulist representatives to pray, share stories and insights, listen to one another, and learn from the collective wisdom that emerges, with the goal of forming alliances and seeing if there is any desire to sustain our efforts beyond 2024. 

It is our desire that the Summit will inspire individuals and groups to recognize how their current activities and ministries can contribute to reducing polarization within our Church and across the country. We hope that all Summit participants leave with both the motivation and concrete ideas to purposefully address polarization. This includes addressing it within their respective work, ministries, organizations, academic institutions, and parish-based or campus ministry communities.

Who will be there?

There will be two distinct groups of over 100 invited participants for the event. Approximately half of the attendees will be leaders, academics, and media experts who are actively involved in efforts to reduce polarization. They will bring expertise in various fields such as reconciliation, race relations, intercultural communication, mediation, consensus building, and pastoral ministry. The remaining 50% of the participants will consist of members from the Paulist priests, seminarians, associates, and deacons. All 100+ participants will be selected from a wide range of backgrounds, including ecclesial, academic, and media spheres, and will represent diverse demographic backgrounds in terms of race, ethnicity, social class/income, gender, age, and more. 

Focus Areas

The Landscape of Polarization: To understand the extent of polarization in the country and the U.S. Catholic Church, and the impact of polarization on our spiritual, emotional, and physical well-being.

Foster Conversations and Dialogue: To invite Catholic leaders, media experts, and Paulist representatives to share their experiences and insights, discovering shared Catholic values despite political differences. The conversations will take place among participants from a diverse array of backgrounds and affiliations, including specific affinity groups such as clergy, lay ministries, academics, media experts, and so on.

Our Tradition, Teachings, and Scripture: To explore our Catholic tradition, teachings, and scriptural heritage that emphasize reconciliation, unity, and peace.

Best Practices: To showcase examples of Catholic leaders, dioceses, parishes, organizations, and other movements that successfully promote healing and reconciliation.

Pastoral Resources and Tools: To facilitate collaborative brainstorming sessions to generate ideas for pastoral resources and tools.

Proposed Schedule

The following schedule is not final but provides an adequate representation of what to expect. Breaks will be included in the schedule but are not listed here.


FRIDAY, APRIL 19

  • 12pm Mass 1pm Lunch
  • 2pm Opening Session: Prayer, Welcome, History and Overview
    Co-Hosts: Rev. Ricky Manalo, CSP, and Sr. Nancy Usselmann, FSP
  • 2:30-4pm Self-Reflection on Polarization: Fr. Tom Gibbons, CSP 4:30-6pm Presentation: Fr. Steven Bell, CSP
    Affinity Groups Discussions

    • The 100+ participants will divide into five affinity groups:
      • Academics
      • Ecclesial Leaders
      • Media Experts
      • National Organizations and Movements
      • Paulist priests, deacons, seminarians, and associates
  • 6-6:30pm Social
  • 6:30-7:30pm Dinner
  • 7:45-8:45pm Keynote
    Two representatives from leading Catholic news resources offer their perspectives and insights on polarization in the United States, moderated by Sr. Nancy Usselmann, FSP, Director of Pauline Center for Media Studies.
    • Jeanette De Melo, Editor in Chief of National Catholic Register
    • Joe Ferullo, CEO and Publisher of National Catholic Reporter

SATURDAY, APRIL 20

  • 7:30 AM Mass
  • 8:15-9 AM Breakfast
  • 9-10:30 AM “Families, Politics, and Polarization”
    Dr. William Doherty, Professor of Family Social Science University of Minnesota, and co-founder of Braver Angels
  • 10:30 AM 15 Mins. Break
  • 10:45-12 PM Small Group Discussion (mixed representation)
  • 12 PM Lunch
  • 1-2 PM Informative Sessions (Round One)
    A set of six informative sessions on polarization from a variety of topics and interests.
  1. Academic: “Repairing the Divide: Moral Imagination and Conflict Transformation in a Polarized United States” by Dr. Aimee Hein, Oblate School of Theology, San Antonio TX
  2. Foundational: “Polarization: The Roots, the Reality, and the Road to Unity” by Fr. Ricky Manalo, CSP, The Paulist Fathers
  3. Media: “Bridging the Divide: A Media Mindfulness Perspective” by Sr. Nancy Usselmann, FSP, Pauline Center for Media Studies
  4. Mediation Skills: “Conflict Resilience: Building Capacity for Having Difficult Conversations” by Bob Bordone, J.D., Senior Fellow at Harvard Law School
  5. Racism: “Racism, Racial Justice, and Polarization” by Gloria Purvis, African American Catholic public scholar, podcaster, and Whole Life activist
  6. Spirituality: “The Church’s Mission in a Polarized World” by Fr. Aaron Wessman, GHM, Vicar General of Glenmary Home Missioners
  • 2 PM 30 Mins. Break
  • 2:30-3:30 PM Informative Sessions (Round Two)
    Participants choose a second session from the above list.
  • 3:30 PM 15 mins. Break
  • 3:45-5 PM Mid-Point Process Check-In
    Facilitated by Bob Bordone, J.D., Senior Fellow at Harvard Law School and on the Advisory Committee of the Catholic Common Ground Initiative
  • 6:00 PM Dinner
  • 7:30-8:45 PM Best Catholic Practices
    A panel discussion on national movements and organizations who are already engaged in the work of depolarization, moderated by Fr. Ricky Manalo, CSP
    • The Braver Angels Movement: Rebecca Cataldi
    • The Bernardin Center (Catholic Common Ground Initiative): TBA
    • The Focolare Movement: Matteo Pota & Kate O’Brien

SUNDAY, APRIL 21

  • 7:30-8:15 AM Breakfast
  • 8:15 AM Opening Prayer & Summary Points from Friday and Saturday
  • 9-9:30 AM Personal Reflection
  • 9:30-10 AM Affinity Group Reflection
  • 10:15-11:15 AM Moving Forward: Where Do We Go from Here?
  • 11:00 AM-12 PM Sunday Mass: The Fourth Sunday of Easter